Misinformation is your uncle at a barbie passing on some dodgy story he picked up on a building site. Honest stuff-up. He heard it off John’o the brickie’s labourer and he’s just passing it down the line.
Disinformation is a completely different animal. It’s a product, someone built it, someone paid for it, and they know exactly what they’re doing. It’s made to mislead you, on purpose.
Your uncle made a mistake you can forgive. The other’s done on purpose and the people behind it should be called out.
First, the Wind Farm They Want Dead
So let me show you a live one, this is playing out right now.
There’s an outfit called Coalition for Conservation (C4C), and they’re throwing everything they’ve got at killing a clean energy project on Sydneys door step.
The Pines Wind Farm is out near Oberon in the Central Tablelands. It mostly sits inside a pine plantation.
It’d be the biggest clean energy project in the main grid, 250 wind turbines, enough power for 1.25 million homes. And the site is about as good as it gets. It’s close to Sydney, where the power actually gets used, it sits right next to an existing 500kV transmission line, so it barely needs a new power line built at all. If any project should be an easy yes, it’s this one.
I’ve Hunted That Forest My Whole Life
Here’s what Coalition for Conservation are banking on. They hope you’ve never been out to these forests. Fair enough, most people haven’t. But I have. And they’re not really forests at all. They’re pine plantations.
If you’ve spent any time out there, you’ll know the feeling. You’re driving through the plantation, you come over the top of a hill or round a bend, and that’s it. The whole place is desolate. Harvested. Not a tree to be seen. Like a wasteland.
Coalition for Conservation want you picturing some untouched old-growth forest under threat. It’s not. It’s literally a pine timber factory.
And it’s a working factory about to earn its keep twice over. The turbines go on state-owned plantation run by Forestry Corporation, the developers pay for the privilege. They even have to fund replacement plantation at least twice the size of the patch they build on. Forestry Corporation didn’t have this forced on them either. They went out looking for it, because for a state-owned agency it’s a fresh income stream. Clean power for over a million homes, money back to a public agency, and the timber crop rolls on. That’s a win for just about everyone.
So when Coalition for Conservation dress a pine plantation up as bulldozing a “national heritage area,” and wave around endangered species that actually live in the World Heritage park next door. It’s less than honest. They borrow the moral weight of the wilderness next door and staple it onto an industrial woodlot. And the whole campaign is counting on you not understanding that sleight of hand. The truth is the majority of the proposed wind farm sits inside a pine plantation.
So Who's Behind Coalition for Conservation?
If you pull up the public charity register and go over to their website, it gets clear fast.
Coalition for Conservation parade around former MPs and try and pull the wool over our eyes with names that end in (AM) Member of the Order, or (AO) Officer of the Order. That means something to them. The rest of us just want cheaper power, so I’m less impressed.
Coalition for Conservation started in 2018 as the conservative voice for climate action. Then it pivoted, and the whole game became obstruction. Nuclear, nuclear, nuclear, and knee-capping the stuff that actually works.
Don’t take my word for it. In April 2024 their own climate ambassador walked out. Matt Kean, ex-NSW Liberal energy minister, put it in a letter to the chairman. Said the place had become obsessed with nuclear.
So who actually runs this “conservation” charity now? Buckle up because it makes more sense when you know who’s pulling the strings.
The chairman, Larry Anthony, is a former Federal President of the Nationals and founding director of the lobbying firm SAS Group. That’s the outfit that lobbied for Shenhua’s $1.2 billion Watermark coal mine.
The CEO, Cristina Talacko, runs GLOW Strategies, an advisory firm on energy and critical minerals. She signed the international pledge at COP28 to triple nuclear power by 2030.
Their media and operations director, Zoe Hilton, has a day job that tells you plenty. She’s a senior energy analyst at the Centre for Independent Studies, the think tank whose reported past donors include coal, oil and gas names like BHP, Shell and Western Mining. She co-wrote the flagship paper claiming the whole energy transition is built on “flaws.” She writes pieces for the Australian and the AFR against renewables and for nuclear. She even puts out videos arguing renewables aren’t the cheapest power, which is the exact opposite of what the CSIRO found.
The deputy chair, Dr Sarah Lawley, is an energy professional who started out on uranium projects and is listed as an advocate with Nuclear for Australia.
On the board you’ll also find Patrick Gibbons, who ran regulatory affairs for the gas and power giant ENGIE, did corporate affairs for aluminium maker Alcoa, and headed the energy retailers’ lobby. And Kerry Chikarovski, former NSW Liberal leader turned registered lobbyist.
One of the patrons? Trevor St Baker. He owns the Vales Point coal-fired power station and founded SMR Nuclear Technology, a nuclear reactor company.
And among the ambassadors lending their names, Arthur Sinodinos, who before the Senate chaired the coal explorer Blackwood Coal and sat on the board of Cuesta Coal.
Add it up. An “environmental charity” run, almost top to bottom, by coal, gas and nuclear lobbyists.
The Bloke Who Keeps Turning Up
Here’s what really got my attention. Turning up on their Facebook page giving talks, and out at Oberon in person, is a bloke called Steven Nowakowski. Cartographer, long-time environmentalist, who took a North Queensland wind farm all the way to the Federal Court to stop it and lost. He’s also, in his own words, gone “pro-nuclear.” Reckons nuclear is “a very good solution.” So here’s a conservationist who fights wind farms and barracks for reactors, turning up at a conservative charity chaired by a coal lobbyist, at the exact project they’re gunning for. I’m not joining the dots for you. I’m just saying it’s giving me an uncomfortable feeling.
And this isn’t my first run-in with Nowakowski. A while back I made a reel about what he calls his “truth map,” which was meant to show the scale of the renewables rollout, and The Australian ran it like proof of an invasion. The only problem was, it was full of projects that had already been cancelled or knocked back. I found a handful of dead wind farms on it in about five minutes, on my phone, on my smoko. When the federal energy minister’s office went through the thing, they reeled off project after project on there that wasn’t going ahead. Moonlight Range, cancelled. Chalumbin, withdrawn. On it went. Nowakowski even put a disclaimer on it admitting he couldn’t guarantee it was accurate. A truth map that couldn’t vouch for its own truth.
And the nuclear drum they keep banging? Take the government’s own scientists. The CSIRO says nuclear can’t put a watt into our grid before about 2040. Takes at least 15 years to build. Costs two to six times firmed renewables. Every year we chase it is a year the coal and gas keep selling. That’s not a climate policy. It’s a stall. And a stall is worth a fortune to whoever’s still burning the stuff.
Step back and look at what’s happening. The best-sited, biggest clean energy project in the country, the one that answers every objection these people ever raised, and they’re fighting it harder than anything. That’s the tell. When a project ticks every box you claimed to care about and you still want it dead, the boxes were never the point.
Strip away the green logo and the letters after their names, and here’s what I reckon this really is. This was never about a forest. It’s about nuclear. A crew of nuclear and coal backers stalling every clean energy project they can, for as long as they can, so we keep burning coal while we wait years for reactors that might never come.
There’s a lot more to this than one charity and one wind farm. There are other crews in this fight I haven’t touched yet, and the names and the money behind them are where I’ll be spending a fair bit of my time over the coming while.
I’ll keep asking. Let’s see what happens.












They tried to do the same thing at Carcoar. 15-20 years ago. Thank you.
If you can’t beat them, bamboozle them? Fake political parties, fake coalitions?